Custom Men’s Engagement Rings: A Complete Guide For Navigating A New Tradition

By  Mac Molli
Updated on 03/13/24
Custom Men’s Engagement Rings: A Complete Guide For Navigating A New Tradition

Custom Men’s Engagement Rings: A Complete Guide For Navigating A New Tradition

By  Mac Molli
Updated on 03/13/24

Part of the Engagement

Custom Men’s Engagement Rings: A Complete Guide For Navigating A New Tradition

By  Mac Molli
Updated on 03/13/24

Who says women are the only ones who get to wear an engagement ring? These days, a growing number of men are electing to show their commitment by wearing an engagement ring of their own. 

On top of that, modern grooms are customizing their rings by selecting unique materials and one-of-a-kind inscriptions. If you’re curious to learn more about custom men’s engagement rings, then check out our comprehensive guide. 

What Are Custom Men’s Engagement Rings?

If you’re like most people, you probably picture a woman proudly flashing a glimmering diamond ring when you hear the term engagement ring

While female wedding rings are definitely expected, more and more men are choosing to wear engagement rings these days. 

In fact, 5% of men reported wearing an engagement ring (also called a mangagement ring). Plus, a full 67% of men said they’d be comfortable wearing this type of ring

Why Choose Custom Engagement Rings for Men?

Why Choose Custom Engagement Rings for Men?

Male engagement rings are relatively unknown, but they’re not a new idea. In fact, department store L. Bamberger & Co. advertised a line of male rings way back in 1926. Unfortunately, these rings were too ahead of their time and didn’t take off. 

That started changing in the 1940s when actor Humphrey Bogart was spotted wearing a wedding ring. Nowadays, men, especially Millennials, are choosing to wear both wedding and engagement rings. 

Men are opting to wear engagement rings for a number of reasons including: 

  • Showing commitment – Rather than one partner being “taken,” more and more couples are showing their mutual attachment through engagement rings. 
  • Honoring cultural traditions – Wearing a male engagement ring is commonplace in countries like Sweden, Argentina, and Chile.
  • Same-sex marriage – As more countries legalize same-sex marriage, the number of men wearing engagement rings also increases. 
  • Celebrity influence – Singers Michael Bublé and Ed Sheeran have worn engagement rings, causing an increase in popularity amongst the general public. 

Choosing a Custom Engagement Ring for Him

Now that you have a better understanding of what men’s engagement rings are and why they’re important, it’s time to look at choosing a custom engagement ring for your male partner. 

With so many options on the market, choosing the perfect ring can be tricky. We recommend using a combination of your budget and your partner’s style to guide your decision. 

The next few sections will cover everything you need to know about materials, sizing, customization, and buying options for male engagement rings.

Male Engagement Ring Materials

Male Engagement Ring Materials Precious Metals Alternative Metals Other Materials

Because custom mens engagement rings are such a new idea, the sky’s the limit when it comes to designing a band. You could go the more traditional route and choose from a number of precious metals, or you could look into alternative materials

Precious Metals

  • Rose gold – An alloy made from a combination of gold and copper, rose gold is a pinkish-red metal that’s a subtle, yet unique choice for a male ring. 
  • Yellow gold – A true classic when it comes to engagement rings, yellow gold is strong and durable, meaning it will look beautiful throughout your entire life. 
  • White gold – Made by combining gold, nickel, and zinc, white gold looks like silver but is tarnish-proof and scratch resistant. 

Alternative Metals

  • Damascus steel – One of many alternative metals used in men’s engagement rings, Damascus steel is made by twisting two types of stainless steel together to create unique patterns that resemble wood grain. This material is durable and won’t tarnish.
  • Tantalum – A grey-blue metal originally used for industrial products, tantalum rings are hypo-allergenic and break-resistant. They’re also one of the most precious contemporary metals around. 
  • Tungsten – Originally used in light bulb filaments, tungsten is a popular metal for men’s rings. It’s durable, scratch resistant, and requires little maintenance. 

Other Materials

  • Dinosaur bone – One of the more unique ring materials, dinosaur bone rings feature a strip of crushed-up dinosaur fossils as part of their design. They come in a variety of colors and are sure to start a conversation. 

Carbon fiber – Lightweight and incredibly durable, carbon fiber rings are an easy, low-maintenance choice for the man in your life.

Choosing the Right Ring Size

Selecting the perfect ring size is one of the trickiest and most stressful parts of buying an engagement ring for your partner, especially if you’re trying to keep your plans a secret. 

Luckily, there are lots of ways to overcome this challenge. The easiest way is to measure the diameter of a ring your partner already owns. Then, use a ring sizing chart to convert the measurement to a ring size. 

If your partner doesn’t have any other rings, you can measure their finger using a length of string, then convert the measurement using a ring sizer chart. Alternatively, most jewelry companies will send you a complimentary plastic ring sizer. 

It’s also important to keep in mind that most rings can be resized after purchase. That said, certain materials like carbon fiber and tungsten cannot be resized, so steer clear of these materials if you’re worried about fit. 

Customizing a Male Engagement Ring

Customizing a Male Engagement Ring

While you can certainly purchase an engagement ring off the shelf, designing a ring to your exact specifications is much more fun and unique. 

On the most basic level, you can choose from a number of materials, shapes, widths, settings, colors, and designs. 

Then, depending on the material you select, you may be able to engrave your partner’s ring, perhaps with your initials or an important date. 

Regardless of what you choose, make sure to keep your partner’s preferences and personal style in mind. 

Where to Buy Custom Men’s Engagement Rings

Some well-known jewelry companies offer a small selection of male engagement rings and men’s wedding rings but for the time being, this is not the norm. 

Not only do smaller online retailers offer a bigger selection and more competitive prices, but they also give customers more choices in terms of customization. Some of our favorites include:

  • Blue Nile Men’s Engagement Ring Collection – Featuring gorgeous metals and dazzling stones, Blue Nile’s rings make just as much of a statement as women’s do. 
  • Revolution Jewelry – Offers hundreds of customization options including materials, color inlays, and engraving. 
  • Shane Co. – Has lots of individual and paired rings designed with same-sex couples in mind. 


How Much Should Custom Male Engagement Rings Cost?

How Much Should Custom Male Engagement Rings Cost?

Unlike the common wisdom that says an engagement ring should cost the equivalent of three months of salary, there aren’t any rules around the price of male engagement rings. 

While not having any guidelines to follow may feel unnerving, it frees you up to make a well-informed decision based on your preferences and other proposal costs

That said, men’s engagement rings (even customized ones) tend to cost much less than the $6,000 average for female engagement rings

Naturally, the amount you spend is dependent on the materials you select, any precious stones included in the design, and other customization you add. With that in mind, expect to pay anywhere from $100 to $10,000.

FAQs - Custom Men’s Engagement Rings

Who Should Pay For a Man’s Custom Engagement Ring? 

If you think of an engagement ring as a gift, it makes sense that the person giving the ring should be the one to pay for it. The same is true for purchasing men’s wedding rings

Which Hand Should a Man Wear an Engagement Ring On? 

If you want to follow tradition, then a man should wear an engagement ring on the left hand until the wedding day. After getting married, a man can use his engagement ring as a wedding band or move the engagement ring to the right and wear a wedding band on the left hand. 

Same-sex couples might choose to wear their engagement rings on their right hand. This has been a long-standing tradition, even before marriage equality became law. 

Choose the Right Engagement Ring for Your Man

Now that you have a complete picture of what custom men’s engagement rings are, we hope you feel more comfortable selecting the right one for your partner. Just remember–you can’t go wrong with your partner’s favorite color or a thoughtful inscription. 

Once you’ve got the ring sorted out, make sure to check out our Engagement Photo Tips!

You May Also Like: